Topic: Best black liquid eyeliner (non water resistance prefered)
I have tried MAC but not pleased with what it has to offer. Any other suggestion would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Last edited by thaocrockett (2012-02-01 15:05:10)
You are not logged in. Please login or register.
I have tried MAC but not pleased with what it has to offer. Any other suggestion would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Last edited by thaocrockett (2012-02-01 15:05:10)
I just purchased Lancome yesterday. Haven't tried it yet. I will let you know how it goes. I asked the sales person if it was easy to use. She said YES. I guess I will need to find out!
Last edited by missg (2012-02-01 15:16:15)
Yes, please 
This eyeliner from Clarins works really good, its easy to use and stays all day. The liquid is very dark and when its drydowned it looks like velvet, very nice. I`ve also had the one from MAC, but this one its much more practical.
Thanks. I see Clarins @ Macy's but can't find liquid eyeliners on their website. Hope they carry it @ the store.
Last edited by thaocrockett (2012-02-01 19:46:32)
Hello thaocrockett!
My favorite eyeliner ever is MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack
which is gel eyeliner. I highly recommend it, it's just perfect for the upper lash line, waterline, etc. I use it with a very thin angled brush.
Anyway, for liquid eyeliners, I recently bought this very inexpensive one by Jordana Cosmetics:
It's like a pen eyeliner (liquid) and I LOVE it! It's very inexpensive, the color is very pretty (I have it in Brown though) and I can control it perfectly. It draws both thick and thin lines and I can do the flick on the outer corner without problems. It doesn't say it's waterproof, but it has never smudged on me and it lasts all day.
The packaging and felt tip makes it super easy to apply, so far it's the easiest one I've tried. Instead of the ones that you dip in the pot to grab some product.
I use waterproof mascara so I remove all my eye make up with baby oil and waterproof eye make up remover so I wouldn't know if it's hard to take off.
But for the low price, it's definitely worth a try.
Another one I like (but not love) is
It's super pigmented, it lasts all day and easily removed with water but in my opinion a lot of product comes on the tip and therefore it's not super easy to apply.
Do share which one you'll choose 
Paulina,
I have never thought about the gel eyeliner. I would love to give it a try. Thanks for suggesting 
L'oreal is the best!
Thanks all 
Hi.., I am using L'oreal eyeliner which is one of the best products.The packaging and felt tip makes it super easy to apply, so far it's the easiest one I have tried. I kindly suggest you to try it.
natural minerals makeup
bare mineral makeup
I refuse to wear anything but Milani Liquid Eyeliner, I do however use the waterproof one as it is very humid here but I believe they have one that isn't, I just can't swear by it. It's about $7 and lasts me months, I've used it for years I'm obsessed.
Last edited by Bebette (2012-04-25 01:07:12)
for a drugstore brand i must admit to being impressed with rimmel's liquid eyeliners. removes easily with soap and water but the staying power is pretty impressive. highly pigmented, dries quickly, very fine felt tip applicator.
I really love this one
![]()
It's Maybeline gel eyeliner. Glides on beautifully! And I also like the price
Hey, I have this one too. And I specially loved the price. But I noticed more smudging with Maybelline than MAC.
MAC Fluidline is in my opinion the BEST gel liner there is 
For Lancôme, try Maybelline's Line Stiletto and L'Oreál Paris Lineur Intense with felt tip. They look EXACTLY the same and all three brands are part of L'Oreal Group anyway.
I've never tried Clinique's gel liner but IMO Fluidline by MAC is the best.
Believe it or not, the one from the discount brand NYC.
Now, I haven't tried many, but this one is easy to control, and the fact that I can actually do a nice job with it says a lot for it! 
I really love this one
![]()
It's Maybeline gel eyeliner. Glides on beautifully! And I also like the price
+ 1. Love it - I'm on my second lot... Brilliant!
I always use Lancome Artliner. Soooo easy!

I refuse to wear anything but Milani Liquid Eyeliner, I do however use the waterproof one as it is very humid here but I believe they have one that isn't, I just can't swear by it. It's about $7 and lasts me months, I've used it for years I'm obsessed.
![]()
I'll have to agree, Milani is great! Revlon Colorstay is good too.
I always use Lancome Artliner. Soooo easy!
+1
Mary Kay liquid eye liner
+1 for Mary Kay® Liquid Eyeliner
also Maybelline Line Stiletto and EYESTUDIO Gel Eyeliner

The Maybelline one ++++
also for liquid Studio Liquid Liner from Nyx, been using 3 colors, makes a very fine line and doesn't smudge, comes off easier than gelliner.

I use Loreal HIP gel liner, Bobbie Brown Gel liner (gift from the company), but by far the best.....NYX liner pen. It's like a felt tip marker and easy to control. I can hardly find them at Ulta as they are usually sold out! Cost is about $10.00.
Popular brands and perfumes: