
By: Marlen Harrison
Tuberose Gardenia was the first of Aerin Lauder’s recent line of higher-priced and more exclusive fragrances for the Estee Lauder brand, and it is now the signature scent of and recurring birthday gift for my best friend, Becky, a revolutionary recruiter and human resources specialist in Orlando, Florida. The hot sun and southern heat bring out the glorious floral tones of the first entry in the Private Collection and keep Becky’s nose constantly glued to her wrist.

Next, 2008 witnessed the launch of the sweet, powdery Amber Ylang Ylang – when a bottle finally arrived at my doorstep, it instantly knocked my socks off. As a lover of all things sweet, oriental and powdery, I thought I had gone straight to heaven. Some say it’s too sweet, I just feel as if I’m being enveloped in exotic incense. When I heard there would be a 3rd launch, a fragrance both built around not one, but two different jasmine notes, and that had originally been conceived by Estee herself but never completed, I thought “this is just too much – my poor credit card!”

You see, a trip to Cambodia a few years ago introduced me to jasmine in a way I had never really experienced it before. When I entered my hotel, the incredible Hotel de la Paix in Siem Reap, I was met with a bracelet of fresh jasmine petals. When I entered the elevator that took me to my 2nd floor room, there was a large sculptural bouquet of jasmine blossoms of all varieties perched on a table opposite the doors. As I walked down the deco-modern hallways past black and white photos of Angkor Wat, there were oil burners from which the aroma of jasmine emanated. And what do you think was gently placed on my pillow just moments before I entered my room? I enjoyed this luxury for five days in a row and now jasmine is my favorite floral aroma.

Before I continue, a quick word about the chypre family. I generally think of fragrances like Miss Dior, Ivoire de Balmain, or Chanel No 19 – sometimes green, sometimes earthy, sometimes completely not me. I like the sparkle and the verdant freshness of certain chypre aromas, but overall they feel like a thing of the past, retro, and not in an entirely good way.
When I received my bottle of Jasmine White Moss, the only idea in my head was jasmine blossoms combined with Acca Kappa’s White Moss Eau de Cologne. Boy was I off.
After spraying the fragrance for the first time onto my skin wile on vacation in Boca Raton, I was immediately transported back to the late 1970’s, early 1980’s a time when American stores like Burdines and A&S still existed. In short, I thought of Azuree, Anais Anais, Chanel No 19… Halston dresses, shoulder pads, and Aaron Spelling’s Dynasty. I was immediately disappointed. Where’s my bright, sweet, sometimes slightly dirty jasmine? This was no Acca Kappa sniffalike, it was, rather, a chypre!

I immediately dismissed the fragrance and decided to revisit it when in a different climate and when resigned to dismissing dangerous expectations of what I hoped a fragrance would be rather than getting to know it for what it actually is. Last week I pulled the bottle back out while at home in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania and gave myself a full blast to the chest. Much to my surprise, I was enamored. The familiar associations did return, but this time I thought of those tiny galbanum blossoms, crushed and giving off their creamy, silky aroma, like a rush of cold air across a body on a hot afternoon.
I could detect the sunny bergamot, like drops of ice crystal water. I could enjoy the patchouli warming the scent from its depths. But it was not until hour #2 of its development that I actually found the jasmine in Jasmine White Moss. You see, the focus here is not so much to produce a jasmine scent as it is to build a fragrance around a jasmine accord. Once I understood this, I began to fall in love.

At a time when so many fragrances are quick launches pushed by celebrity names and gifts with purchase, I had forgotten what classic parfumerie was. I’m so used to a fragrance developing within 60 minutes and then drifiting off to forgotten-forever-land, I hadn’t taken the time to just let the fragrance develop on my skin.
Now I sit here, deep into hour #3 of today’s testing and I think I may have forgotten about all of those scents I earlier mentioned the fragrance reminding me of. Could the quality of this fragrance really be remarkable? Or could it be that in parfum version, a fragrance really does reveal its best assets? Or maybe, just maybe, it’s that Jasmine White Moss has me rethinking what I thought I knew about chypre and willing to step back into the ‘80’s.
Summary: A new, green, floral chypre based on an unreleased 1980’s Estee Lauder composition and completed by Aerin Lauder in 2009.
Pros: Anyone who loves this category of fragrance will likely be enchanted by the predictable but also velvety smooth composition; the ancillary products (currently the body crème) is almost as magnificent as the fragrance itself; perhaps my favorite take on the galbanum/moss chypre accord.
Cons: Not much noticeable jasmine for a jasmine-themed fragrance during its first hour; definitely a throwback to 1970’s and 1980’s perfumery - there’s nothing cute, modern or fruity about this one; the drydown of the pure parfum reveals the warmth of those earthy chypre basenotes more so than the Eau de Parfum; a higher pricepoint than most of Lauder’s scents, though it is of course part of the “Private Collection”.
Notes: "Black Currant Bud Absolute, Galbanum Absolute, Bergamot Absolute, Aerin's Jasmine Sambac Absolute, Estée's Ylang Ylang Absolute, Estée's Jasmine Absolute, Violet, Orange Flower Absolute, Orris, Patchouli Heart Absolute, Vetiver Absolute,
White Moss Mist Absolute (an Estée Lauder exclusive).” from EsteeLauder.com
Reminds me of: Gucci Envy, Chanel Cristalle, Chanel Bel Respiro, Balmain Vent Vert
Designer’s Description: “Radiant green and white floral freshness in a passionate yet elegant blend of modern and classic ingredients...the shared creation of both Aerin and Estée Lauder.
The fragrance is an intensely lush green floral chypre scent, with an opulent white bouquet surrounded by delicate moss, rich woods and fifteen 100% pure natural fragrance Absolutes.
The Parfum Spray is the jewel in the collection...the purest expression of the Jasmine White Moss experience. The sleek bottle features a cap embedded with natural semi-precious gems including White Jade, dark and light Lapis, Sodalite, Black Agate, Mother of Pearl and Blue Lace Agate stones.
The stones selected for each cap are different, making each cap unique.
‘I'm delighted to share with you the third fragrance in my Private Collection. It was begun by Estée in the late '80s, kept in a vault, and only recently rediscovered. I've added some notes of my own to complete it. I hope you'll like it as much as I do.’ - Aerin Lauder.
Number of times tested: Numerous wearings on whole body.
Number of sprays applied for this review: One on the back of hand.
Fragrance Strength: Parfum.
Parfum Development: (Linear / Average / Complex) The bright bergamot of the topnotes rather quickly gives way to the warmer iris, patchouli, vetiver and oakmoss notes, though these notes never really make a full-fledged appearance. The middle notes of flowers melt beautifully together such that the emphasis isn’t as much a floral bouquet as “a hint of a garden on the afternoon breeze”.
Now and then, just when I think the composition has fully relaxed, the bergamot reappears with echoes of jasmine petal and powdery iris.
The final drydown, and I can only assume this to be the exclusive white moss accord, almost has a purest of the pure musks feel to it – round, sweet, and airy.
Longevity: (Short / Average / Long-lasting): I’m testing the pure parfum and it lasts and lasts and lasts...In fact, one spray to my chest got me through an entire day (thank you for that, Ms. Lauder!)
Sillage: (A Little / Average / A Lot): Again, as is typical with pure parfums, the trail of scent is quite impressive.
Note About the Packaging: The rectangular glass Private Collection bottle is back, this time with a cap of cut squares of White Jade, dark and light Lapis, Sodalite, Black Agate, Mother of Pearl and Blue Lace Agate stones for the pure parfum, and simple, textured gold for the Eau de Parfum.
There is a solid perfume that looks like a work of art from the 1910’s or ‘20’s, a magnificent, heavy square solid with a bejeweled swiveling lid that hangs from a rectangular gold chain link.
Rating (out of 10): 9
Images: EsteeLauder, Kpjas
Author: Marlen Harrison
Guest writer
Creator and Editor of PerfumeCritic.com, Marlen Harrison was also author of Basenotes.com's ADDICTED column and one of the community's moderators. Marlen has been a regular contributor to NowSmellThis blog, BeautyAddictMag, and The Washington Blade. He is currently completing his PhD in English Composition and TESOL and teaches at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.
Despite all the negativity of folk who claim "it's NO Diorella "-
I really love this scent.
It's glorious in its own right, and a very WET feeling chypre to me-
As opposed to the dry, witty, ascerbic ones.
Glad you enjoyed it, too ! :)
Thanks for the comments! Not only is the fragrance beautiful but the bottle is stunning and the ancillary products are equally luxurious.
I recently sniffed and then bought this while shopping a few weeks ago. I completely agree with Marlen that while both versions are good the parfum has something extra to it that makes it markedly better. I was disappointed in the first two Private Collection releases as both Tuberose Gardenia and Amber Ylang Ylang never reached cruising altitude for me. Jsamine White Moss succeeds for me where those two, did not.
As a South Florida ex-patriate I have to admit the mention of Burdine's and Jordan Marsh take me back to the 80's when both of these stores still existed and where a young man in South Florida went to get his style fix.
I want it! I love jasmine (but spell it with an 'e')!
You brought back a part of my past! How well I remember Burdines and Jordan Marsh! I loved your review and definitely need to try this one. For many years I wore various Estee Lauder perfumes but gradually drifted away. Maybe it's time to come back.
Holy cow! What an awesome review that tells me exactly everything I wanted to know about this fragrance. It's been in my wishlist for awhile but now it's moving up to a "must try!"
Great review, Marlen! I have not tried this yet but now I must, I did not real that there was so much galbanum in it. The first perfume in this collection dispappointed me and I had not bothered with the second. I always liked the older Lauders the best anyway, so I hope this really is a throwback, that would be right in my ballpark.
Lovely personal review Marlen, I really enjoyed it!! Perfumes of Private Collection by Estee Lauder are really fabulous. Jasmin is one of my favorite flowers, but Amber-Ylang is my favorite in this collection. Just exactly as you said it - sweet, exotic, oriental, intoxicating.
Become a member of this online perfume community and you will be able to add your own reviews.
Raw Materials
Fragrant Horoscope
Niche Perfumery
New Fragrances
Home Scents
Natural Perfumes
Art Books Events
Fragrances and Cultures
Vintages
Columns
Fragrance Reviews
Interviews
Fragrantica
Perfumes
Noses
Groups
Notes
Search by notes
Videos
Colors
Designers
Countries
Parent Companies
Industries
New Reviews new
Juicy Couture
Viva La Juicy Nice Stuff for Nice Girl
Givenchy
Very Irresistible Electric Rose
Tim McGraw
Faith Hill Soul2Soul for Her
Tim McGraw
Tim McGraw Soul2Soul for Him
Roberto Torretta
Roberto Torretta Eau de Toilette
Miriam Ocariz
Miriam Ocariz Eau de Toilette
United Scents of America
New York
United Scents of America
New Jersey
United Scents of America
California
United Scents of America
Florida
Donna Karan
DKNY Women Summer 2012
Cartier
Roadster Sport Speedometer Limited Edition
Popular brands and perfumes: