Chloe Rose Edition Chloe for women

This version is the original + added charm :) It's sweeter, juicier, softer, more playful, lovable and charismatic. I wish this was the widely available version and the original -- a limited edition ;)

This is certainly not the same as the original. It's the bottle design that is the same, not the fragrance. This fragrance smells a bit more youthful than the original [I'm 23 and the original is a bit too 'grandmother-y' for my taste]. I love rose so I had to try this one. It's a light floral with rose notes and I really enjoy it.

it's better than the original. can't love it more!!!

Compared to the EDT version, I prefer this one. It's softer and has less of that peppery sharp note. Ironically, the staying power is better with the EDT, while Chloe Rose Edition doesn't last that much.

It's very much like original Chloe but with a stronger rose note. I really like it. Staying power is great. Unforitunately my husband is allergic to all Chloes - just all of them, maybe it's some component not sure which. But I wear it anyway, just staying in a different room :)

Tested on my skin yesterday and found it EXACTLY the same as the original Chloe EDP. I have a mini Chloe EDP and I think it doesn't work with my chemistry, it becomes sharp and generic on my skin and sometimes it gives me a headache. Therefore, all I have to say is that if reformulation is needed, then it must be done properly-a change in the concentration of the initial ingredients is the first thing that has to be done.
This one has the same intensity and the same feeling as the Chloe EDP. Too bad !

The Rose edition is the EDP, so the reviewers who say this is a different scent maybe are familiar with the EDT? To my nose, the EDP and EDT are distinctly different. Also, different jasmine crops, rose-growing seasons, etc. may account for others noticing a different fragrance in Rose. Perfume formulations change all the time. I wish I hadn't missed trying this Rose edition for myself.

..o my.... this is the SAME EXACT SCENT. straight off the nordstrom website:
"Celebrate the enchanting and sensual essence of spring with the original Chloé Eau de Parfum, in this limited-edition packaging tied with a rose-colored bow"

they added a friggin bow to it people, the smell is the same. *le sigh

It is not the same as the original. I love the original but somehow cant wear it, smells like grandma on me, TOO floral. But i like it when my friend wears it. But rose edition is MY chloe:D great as an office perfume.

This version is still quite sophisticated but also really creamy and a tad soapy. I can imagine in a hot country it would become cloying so I would keep this one for the cooler months. Its pretty but I'm im just not a fan of magnolia in anything - maybe that's what puts me off. A well made fragrance but not for me! :)

I thought this smelled exactly like the original. when I first saw the pink ribbon I thought maybe it was for breast cancer awareness or something..
A pretty scent.. just like the original.

Chloe Rose Edition smells rather similar to the original Chloe. I was a bit disappointed at first to be completely honest. I guess I expected something more rosy and fresh rather than soapy and strong.

I wasn't a fan of the original Chloe, so I'm finding it difficult to enjoy this flanker. The roses are of course more pronounced in this fragrance, however I tend to get a lot more of the peony and freesia too. There is too much in the way of stuffy floral-scented soaps for my liking.

As a child I used to use a rose-scented talcum powder after my baths, and in some ways Chloe Rose Edition reminds me of that smell. It's not a cringe-worthy scent, but to my nose it comes across as being dusty and ancient. It's what I'd imagine a period-style house smelling like.

I prefer roses when they're more jammy and concentrated, not so clean and pristine. However I have no doubt that this fragrance will have many fans, as many as the original has, no doubt. Chloe Rose Edition is just not for me.

The longevity was impressive I found, and the sillage somewhere between cloying and being acceptable. It's a pretty straight-forward scent, so I'd advise only to approach if you liked the original 2008 release of Chloe EDP.

There is something quite sweet about this version of Chloe. Although everything pretty much lines up with the Original Eau De Parfum- from the First initial burst of rose to the sweet and faint drydown but there is a sweetness about this scent that makes it quite innocent and feel like its quite young in a sense and i say that because when I smell this I think of innocent girls running through fields of flowers and getting their white cotton dresses dirty. I like the earthy element of this edition although it is essentially the Original scent with a new pretty bow. But I couldnt resist purchasing this edition of Chloe. That bottle is just to beautiful not to have (again)

Even though it is vey simillar to the original perfume, it is not the same. But if you love the original Chloe, you will probably love this one, too. I love it, and I'm wearing it right now. :)

lighter, fresher, more rosy, and not as long lasting as the edt or edp.

As posted on the Nordstrom website:

"Celebrate the enchanting and sensual essence of spring with the original Chloé Eau de Parfum, in this limited-edition packaging tied with a rose-colored bow."

Same juice, new bow.

I adore this. It's slightly stronger and sweeter than the original Chloe, and the smell of rose stands out a little more. I have switched this one to my signature.

This perfume is EXACTLY THE SAME as the Edp.

I saw this at Nordstrom and asked if they had a tester. The salesperson grabbed the regular bottle and was about to spray me, but I said, "No! I want to try the rose edition. Do you have a tester of that?" He said the fragrance is exactly the same as the original, but they put a pink bow on it as a special edition for Spring.

Nordstrom's description says this is the "original Chloe Eau de Parfum," which means it's the exact same liquid as the regular EDP, and the description also specifically says "limited edition packaging."

This version of Chloe is pretty close to the original, it just seemed a tad fresher and more likely to catch the heart of those who didn't fall for Chloe and the intense EDP. Or is this the placebo effect of the pink bow? I usually stray from scents that showcase the rose, but this is actually a very tender wet type of rose surrounded by other buds here and there. The opening is fresh and juicy, I believe there must be some red fruit involved. The middle is deeper, flowery and rosey. I'm amazed by how amber stood out on my skin towards the drydown, but thats what happens when I wear the original. It really adds some serious depth to the scent and rounds out the watery feeling of the floral mid-stage. The aquatic notes are bordering an artificial feeling, but it's barely detectable. This is a potent perfume and the lasting power is very good.I'm starting to like it a lot, because it doesn't have this melancholic vibe of the original version, which I love. A very cheerful fragrance.

actually....for me this is much more fresher on my skin than the original...hated the original on me because it turned a stale metal cheap woody rose in a drydown on my skin with a powder puff bathroom cleaner undertone that really got on my nerves..this does not...this is femme and lighter i think..all the notes are not listed....some of the notes are different! so this is a different scent on different skin!

For me, the original EDP and EDT were rosy enough as is. The beauty of these fragrances was exactly in the un-mundane interpretation and framing of the rose element. Here, in the new 'rose' version, you can definitely feel the added rose, but it's a straighforward rose scent that I think just simplifies the entire fragrance and takes away everything we love about this line of Chloe. I just can't get why they decided to go and ruin a what was already a great thing. Dissappointing!

I was so excited to try this new one because I have loved the original Chloe EDP for a few years now, and I'm also loving the more recent Love, Chloe. (Love, love, love! Over-use of the word, but justified in this case.) They both work beautifully with my chemistry -- they have never turned sour or over-sweet on me the way so many others have done.
So I eagerly sprayed some on my wrist, thinking "Yay! Another Chloe to love!!".
But it smelled just like the original on me: lovely, smokey-rosey, rich in both senses of the word -- and I already have it. Sigh.
At least I saved my $90 plus tax.

I haven't tried the original, so I can't compare them, but I liked it. First I couldn't notice the rose which I desire to sniff ,I think because of the other scents in the store. When I got out for fresh air, I realized the rose. It's elegant and visible but not striking.

I tested this today after recently buying the original and I can tell the difference but it's very subtle and I think the original is far more balanced. The rose that's been emphasised in this one is more like synthetic rose talc than a pure heady rose and that seems to dominate the other notes, so I'm very pleased I went for the original.

I agree, it smells like the edp version, I don't understand the point of it.

I agree - it smells exactly the same as the original...such a shame:(

Like lucifera said, its the same Chloe fragrance in a slightly different packaging :/

I had the change to try this, IMHO its just like the original but they just put a pink ribbon on the bottle instead of the original, didn't smelled the rose..
i'd stick to the original ;-)