Big Pony 2 Ralph Lauren for men

A musky chocolate scent with very little personality but adequately executed. Not as bad as some would imply, the musk and chocolate do interplay rather well here, but unfortunately there is very little movement nor any character. It sprays on a skin scent and dries down as linear as it came and is gone around the three hour mark.
This works very well as a unisex blend and I imagine it may actually adapt better to certain skin types than the other three in the Big Pony collection. The chocolate is rather light and thus the musk lifts its higher range qualities forward, implying almost some form of white chocolate.
The thing to keep in mind with Big Pony #2 is that it acts as nothing more than a skin scent and if you are looking for projection or a bit more substance you will not find it here.
A rather synthetic chocolate musk affair, certainly not groundbreaking or worth seeking out, but as enjoyable as a cheap bar of chocolate at the candy store.

#2 is a nice scent. It's sensual and warm. My boyfriend wears it and it smells very good on him. But it's not an outstanding perfume.

Seriously this is what can make a industry bankrupt; specially such as RL.
Where has Safari gone? Where has those qualities gone?
This is obviously a copy just like mannnnnnnnnnnnny routine etudes noses do and release. The world don't need such ordinary thing for perfume addicts or don't need perfume addict if it gonna exist.
Just a fresh aquatic citric chilly mood and nothing else.

i hate to be kinda judgmental on races but i think there are gonna be alot of Caucasians who don't like this fragrance... i actually don't have it but ive tested it twice and both times i had ppl sniffin my arm, neck at church or at work.

Tested one of these each day for 6 days: Prada Amber, Tom Ford Vetiver, John Varvatos, Chanel Egotiste, YSL Pour Homme, and this (#2 Pony) was the only compliment i received over that period of time-all by women...so i bought it.

Sexy member of the Polo team is a light and pleasant fougere oriental. Only two notes are listed but there are other players in this for sure. In the opening I detect light citrus. And there is musk for sure after it settles. The chocolate note is misleading there is no cocoalike chocolate note in this. This is more like vanilla milkshake.

Pony number 2 is a good fragrance but there are many others like this which are better (armand basi silver nature, jacomo rouge, Perry Ellis 360 white etc). So it is not very original. The worst part of this nice cologne is the longevity. 4 hours max. If you like other Ralph Lauren fragrances you will probably like this one as well. It is non offending for sure.

Sillage: 6/10
Scent: 7/10
Longevity: 5/10

I don't get the dark chocolate, and I certainly don't get anything specific out of Big Pony 2. It reads to me like a spicy, cinnamon-type musk. There's a heated amber lurking around in there. $65 for this? Really?

Designated as 'sensual' on the flacon if my memory serves me. A lovely, sweet gourmand type smell to my nose, sweet and somewhat sensual, but also very fleeting - I gave it a couple of strong sprays on the same part of the arm and within an hour it was barely there. If I'd sprayed the original green bottle twice I'd be smelling it into next week!

I've decided to try all the ponies again, starting with the more interesting one with chocolate, and it's much better than the gassy slop I was first introduced to.
First spray is of a very fresh chocolate, as if chocolate was infused with a juicy, light citrus, like a splash of lemonjuice?
The chocolate/ musk combo is reminiscent of a combo of my own;
I've been given some Jo Malone Grapefruit sample vials that I wasn't fond of by themselves, but mixed with the ultra-chocolate Axe/Lynx Dark Temptation it's alot better! I've always wanted to mix DT with lemon instead, as grapefruit is quite harsh.
Pony2 is almost what I want, but not quite.
I also have to mark it down on projection.

I hate how many people are dissing this fragrance, it has to be my most complimented cologne, it will not smell very good to men, but to women it is out of this world.

An oriental vanilla? This is not! I was expecting something completley different.

This smells like alot of Ralph Lauren for men scents do. Masculine, kinda sporty and fresh. Smells like a classic aftershave splash from the early 90's.

Where the hell is the vanilla/sweet note? Very strange. I can't believe this has chocolate listed as a note.

On the whole it's kind of generic, not something I would usually wear as it wouldn't really suit me.

Not really much else to say really apart from a big thank you to Gyspyparfumista who sent me this in my goodie paackage! :)

I like this one it smells fresh and lively definately a summer scent

It seems that Big Pony 2 was made to be as soft as the other Big Pony´s but, in my humble opinion, chocolate and musk are not the best notes to make VERY soft scents. Maybe that´s why I think this one is a bit weird. It´s too much dilute to be a chocolate-musky fragrance. It smells like hot chocolate made with water instead of milk. Anyway, it´s really soft and won´t offend anybodys´s nose.

All four of the Big Pony colognes are horrible. Very strange and artificial smells.

This is not a copy of Axe Dark Temptation, that seems to be the best smelling mass market deodorant. Axe is a cheap and modernized copy of Thierry Mugler A*Men, this one is... some masculine spicy notes on a soft vanilla base. Where is the chocolate? The scent is soft and powdery and on the skin it sounds worse than on the paper.

Red one and blue one are pretty good.

I got this for my boyfriend for Christmas just by reading the fragrance description and I love it. I wish it lasted longer though...but it is very nice.

The fact that they came out with 4 fragrances can be a turn off. It could mean that they did it simply because they had to.

#2 attracted me the most since it was marketed to be the sensual one. I was a bit disappointed though. I didn't last on my skin and it wasn't sexy enough despite that the aphrodisiacs are there: vanilla and chocolate. This is a case of less is more. Maybe use one main aphrodisiac then add more ingredients to compliment and enhance it. SAFE, NOT A HEAD TURNER.

cheap smelling, axe clone!

Tried all four, was very dissapointed. To me they were all vert similar, not the actual smell, but very boring. They would be loved by some, just not me. #1 actually smelt to me like lemon dish washing liquid.
I looked at the notes of each on this site and thought of mixing them, but I don't think it would make a difference.

Love it or hate it. The first smell i can detect is chocolate... then so kinda sweet stuff. Not a masculine smell, more girly. I won't let my man wear this, i might think he's wearing my perfume. The drydown similar to Carolina Herrera Sexy 212 women. Sillage is good, but not long lasting. Disappointed.

Very cheap chocolate smelling; 1:1 exactly like Axe Dark Temptation deobrant. I like RL fragrances, but this one is just low cost stuff.

I was really excited about the release of this fragrance but after smelling it at Dillards I found it to be a waste of time. I expected so much more from Polo this is truly a disappointment.

i have this one and i love it, doesnt last long though, but its very wearable, BUT i got tired of it already lol
and i didnt got any compliments with this one

I really agree in some of the reviews of my friend Gypsy Perfumista...not on this one...i was so dissapointed, if i want a chocolate fragrance ill rater go for Black Orchid or A Men...even Animale Animale is waaaaaay better.

This actually reminded me a bit of Amen on paper. On my skin however I found no similarities. I didn't get the chocolate note that people have been talking about at all. For the first few hours I kept getting sweet and ambery with cucumber.... then after three hours it just vanished into nothing. I'm glad I only have a sample, because I wont be wearing it again. maybe the other three Big Pony's will be better.

In my opinion this is the last Pony but with an open mind i like the others.In this one the chocolate tune smell very cheap and synthetic, very powdery in a wrong way. With no more multidimensional phases the fragance changes to a caramel-cocoa and ordinary sweet smell. Not my kind of smell.

A chocolate scent for men, kudos RL!! As I smelled this today at my favorite fragrance counter it was the most sensual and gourmand sweet of the four in this line...

I detect some spicy accord and other intangible nuances in this but within 15 minutes the chocolate makes its entrance and lasts all the way to the drydown. The musk is slightly animalic but not too dirty, there is a hint of vanilla to my nose and though a woman could wear this it is manly to me, without the usual suspects. If you've ever smelled mark.'s chocolate orchid imagine you sprayed it on in the morning and after working went out and put on Ultrared by PR, before you were halfway through your 1st drink, this is what you would smell like. Even now in the late drydown I get a hint (only a hint, mind you)of something akin to liquorice or fennel, so there are other things in these frags, they only list the two strongest notes...

Sillage: decent
Longevity: good
Overall: 3.5/5

This is something unusual for RL-a male gourmand oriental, I like how they are thinking outside of the box and I was expecting all of these to be really weak (2 notes in a 4.2 ounce bottle) but they are in fact quite well done and eventually I will collect them all.I have very few "tasty" fragrances like this one, so it goes without saying not everyone will like this but I think it is unique and delicious...

This is an EDT with a simple and straightforward aroma with notes of chocolate very confusing and base notes of amber of good quality. Only smells good, is very subtle and can easily eclipsare aroma. Only worth a base of amber.

The EDT should better be called an EDC.